By Danielle O’Connor, Staff Writer
The Menendez Brothers case is an infamous case from the 90s. Brothers, Lyle and Erik Menendez, were found guilty in the 1989 brutal murder of their parents, Jose and Mary “Kitty” Menendez in their Beverly Hills estate. The case gained significant media attention due to the nature of this crime.
In the 80s and 90s, the media portrayed the Menendez brothers. Initially, they were portrayed as spoiled siblings from Beverly Hills that killed their parents for money. They were seen as troubled youths from a wealthy family, which added intrigue to the story. The coverage often focused on the dramatic details of the murders and their luxurious lifestyle.
As the trial progressed, media narratives shifted to explore themes of abuse, psychological trauma, and family dynamics but it was often overshadowed by the slayings. Interviews with loved-ones went on to prove their claims of long-term parental abuse, prompting claims regarding the abuse to be their motive. Tabloid coverage tended to emphasize their privileged background and the shocking nature of the crimes rather than investigating the psychological factors.
After three-decades have passed, Generation-Z has taken interest in the case. With that said, the case gained a lot of attention yet again, this time on TikTok. People started exploring the case more and it’s safe to say that this case is more than what the media told us in the 80s. The brothers claimed they acted in self-defense, alleging years of physical and emotional abuse from their parents. Videos resurfaced on social media platforms from the courtroom which showed family members testifying and siding with the brothers while confirming the abuse that took place throughout their childhood and adolescent years. Despite these backings, they were convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison without parole.
The case gained even more attention recently due to Netflix releasing a show about the Menendez brothers; “Monsters: The Menendez Brothers.” This series dives into the infamous case; exploring the events leading up to the murders, the psychological factors at play, and the sensational media coverage that followed. It explores themes of trauma, abuse, and the impact of societal perceptions on the trial. By presenting different perspectives, the documentary caused outrage by followers of the case.
Ryan Murphy, American Television writer/director received backlash for his show primarily due to concerns about the way it portrays sensitive themes related to trauma and violence. Critics argued that the show could be seen discussing the brutal murders of Jose and Kitty Menendez way too much and overshadowing the abuse that occurred. Additionally, some expressed concern about the ethical implications of dramatizing such a tragic event for entertainment purposes.CX
Courtesy of Netflix
With all the discussion regarding the abuse resurfacing, the case has been reopened. They are expected to be out of prison by Thanksgiving. Due to the media attention surrounding this case, many students on campus have developed opinions regarding the release of the brothers. After talking with two students (who asked to remain anonymous), it seems as if people are re-thinking the original verdict of this case.
A junior education major shared her opinions regarding the potential release of the brothers.
“I want them out because their parents abused them so they did what they had to do to get out of the situation.”
Another student, a junior fashion-major, shared a similar belief.
“The system failed them.”
As the potential release of the Menendez brothers approaches, many students find themselves reflecting on their case and the factors that contributed to their actions. While opinions vary, a significant number of students express sympathy for Erik and Lyle, viewing them as products of a traumatic upbringing rather than vicious criminals. This ongoing debate not only brings up the conversation of the justice system but also raises important questions about how we perceive individuals shaped by their past. In the coming weeks, we’ll see what happens regarding this case. Will the brothers be released? Who knows.
Be First to Comment